Freedom from Blog

Don't call it a comeback . . . .

Saturday, August 04, 2007

"A Profound Mistake"

I'm really confused by the newly ginned up Democratic candidates' dispute over "the use or non-use of nuclear weapons." I mean, it's nice in theory, to say that "all options are on the table," but I think it's pretty telling that nuclear weapons have been used exactly twice in war--by the United States, in 1945. That's more than 60 years ago, btw. Since then, thousands of these things have been built, but no one with the actual power to order their use has had the poor judgment to use them. And that group includes Richard Nixon and George W. Bush.

Now, I understand that deterrence explains a great deal of the non-use of nuclear weapons. But I think that there's also a moral consideration here, which is that, having seen the horrors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, no American president (or Soviet premier, either) wanted to be responsbile for unleashing such a hell on earth.

Now I'm being told that it's a mark of seriousness to be willing to do that--not because the USSR may start a full-on nuclear exchange, but in the mountains of Pakistan? To my mind, a more serious mark of seriousness would be to just say "no."

Oh, one last thing: Remember that Barry Goldwater pondered using nuclear weapons in Vietnam? Maybe Hillary really is a Goldwater girl after all.

1 Comments:

At 10:35 AM, Blogger Frances said...

These are real differences between Obama and HRC. All the foreign policy luminaries of the Clinton era--Richard Holbrooke, Sandy Berger, Madeleine Albright, Richard Cohen--supported the Iraq invasion. HRC has not distanced herself from any of these folks, nor has she apologized for voting for the war. All these folks and their proteges will be right back in power if she is the nominee.

We don't know exactly what Obama stands for, but he does represent a break from the past. There will at least be new faces in his policy advising team. And even if they're less experienced, their track record won't be one of manifest failures.

If HRC is the Democratic nominee we never will get an "accountability moment" in EITHER PARTY for the grotesque failures of judgment that led us into Iraq. The bipartisan foreign policy establishment that got us into this mess will remain in power in both parties.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home